About Us

We do things a bit differently, and that's the way we like it!



Our church is made up of about 160 members of all ages and from all walks of life. Some come every week, and some come only a few times a year.

We are a theologically diverse congregation affiliated with the PC(USA) and feel that we all have a right to our own beliefs and interpretations of Christianity. Everyone is welcomed, accepted, and loved.

Mission Statement

We are a Community of Christian Disciples with Open Minds, Open Hearts, and Open Arms.

We believe in Open Minds,

for we are on a lifelong journey of learning, about Christ hand his message, about our world, and how to reconcile the two.

We desire to meet and accept people where they are in their own spiritual journey.
We do not seek to judge or intimidate.

We love to discuss and understand different points of view.
We err on the side of grace when there are differences of opinion.

We believe in Open Hearts,

for we invite all to share God’s boundless love, forgiveness, and grace.

As we deepen our relationship with Christ, we invite others to deepen their relationship with Him. We want to share our stories and build meaningful relationships with each other.

We believe in Open Arms,

for we seek to be God’s arms in our church, our community, and our world.

We give all honor, glory, and praise to God, who forms us, calls us, and sends us to be the Body of Christ in the community and the world. Amen.


Our church was founded in 1905 in Fraser. When the congregation grew large enough, they built the historic Fraser Presbyterian Church building which is now a community center (“The Church of What’s Happening Now”). Back then it was difficult for people to travel between Granby and Fraser, so another Presbyterian church formed in 1927, and the congregation eventually purchased the old Lutheran log church building to meet in. In the 1980’s, these two congregations merged to become the “Presbyterian Church of the Eternal Hills,” governed by one board, but still worshiping in the two different locations.  In 1998 our congregations decided to “meet in the middle” and our church in Tabernash was built We began worshiping here in 2002. We’ve been blessed with an amazing building and an even more amazing congregation.

Being Presbyterian

Through the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God, and the communion of the Holy Spirit, we trust in the one triune God, the Holy One of Israel, whom alone we worship and serve.

God comes to us in free and undeserved favor in the person of Jesus Christ who lived, died, and rose for us that we might belong to God and serve Christ in the world. Following Jesus, Presbyterians are engaged in the world and in seeking thoughtful solutions to the challenges of our time.

Presbyterians affirm that God comes to us with grace and love in the person of Jesus Christ, who lived, died, and rose for us so that we might have eternal and abundant life in him. As Christ’s disciples, called to ministry in his name, we seek to continue his mission of teaching the truth, feeding the hungry, healing the broken, and welcoming strangers. God sends the Holy Spirit to dwell within us, giving us the energy, intelligence, imagination, and love to be Christ’s faithful disciples in the world.

More than two million people call the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) their spiritual home. Worshiping in 10,000 Presbyterian congregations throughout the United States, they engage the communities in which they live and serve with God’s love.

This and more information about being Presbyterian can be found on the PC(USA) website at www.pcusa.org.

Our Staff

paula steinbacherRev. Paula Daniel Steinbacher

“Pastor Paula” has been with Church of the Eternal Hills since July of 2014. Paula grew up in Wichita, KS, where her love of God and the church was nurtured through a wonderful church family at Grace Presbyterian. Selected as a “National Presbyterian Honor Scholar,” Paula attended Sterling College in Sterling, KS, and received her Bachelor of Arts in Speech & Theatre, and Language & Literature with an emphasis in Secondary Education. She received her Masters of Divinity degree from Phillips Theological Seminary in Tulsa, OK.

Paula has been married to James Steinbacher since 1992, and together they have 2 children, Addie and Stephen. Paula has worked in youth ministry since her college years, and has served in various professional capacities at churches in Watertown, CT; Winfield, KS; Arkansas City, KS; and Newkirk, OK.

In her free time, Paula loves writing, gardening, making soup, and spending time with James and their pets. Olive, the Boston Terrier, can often be found working alongside Pastor Paula at Church of the Eternal Hills.

jill milesJill Miles, Office Manager

Jill Miles has been the CEH office administrator since 2013, providing clerical support to the pastor as well as the preschool and various church committees and activities. Her previous careers include international marketing specialist for an engineering company and small business owner. She has an MBA from the Thunderbird School of Global Management and speaks Spanish, Chinese, and dog.

janis lundJanis Lund, Treasurer

Janis and her husband Mark moved to Grand County in 2007 and began attending CEH shortly after. Janis was born in Iowa and after graduating from college, lived and worked in Minneapolis, MN for 26 years before relocating to Colorado. Janis worked in banking for 22 years and prior to that worked in public accounting. Since moving to Colorado, she has been involved in a number of organizations holding various board and officer positions. Her hobbies include golfing, skiing, tending to her flower garden, going for walks, and above all enjoying the beautiful Colorado scenery.  Janis loves the friends, fellowship and teaching that CEH has to offer and is happy to have made CEH their church home.

janis lundJulia Macchione, Intentional Faith Development Director

Julia has been with Church of the Eternal Hills since August of 2017. She started as the Preschool Program Director and has shifted to the Intentional Faith Development Director Position. This way, she gets to work with all ages, infants through adults. It is the perfect fit!

Julia grew up in Boulder, Colorado and went to college at the University of Colorado in Boulder. She met wonderful, lifelong friends who encouraged her to grow her faith with God. She received a degree in physiology and a degree in psychology with a certificate of neuroscience. Following her undergraduate career, she met and married Allen Macchione. They have been married for five years this summer and have two children (Sadie and one on the way). She went back to school for her master’s in education from Colorado State University and is licensed as a Colorado Teacher. She has enjoyed working with middle and high school students and cannot wait to grow and learn more about ministry.

Julia loves watching movies while snuggling with her family, dancing to Taylor Swift, drinking coffee, fishing, skiing, hunting, boating, and large family gatherings in Granby.

glenn thompkinsGlen Tompkins, Worship Leader

Glen has led worship at CEH since 2007. He brings years of experience with him as he has served in various churches and Young Life as a worship leader since 1976. He studied music education at Corpus Christi State University. Glen’s musical talents include playing the guitar, piano, flute, drums, and singing lead vocals. He is also a contemporary christian recording artist.

patti applebeePatti Applebee, Choir Director

Patti has been the CEH Choir Director for over 30 years! She studied music at the University of Nebraska. While living in Oklahoma City, she taught piano for 10 years and directed 2 children’s choirs. Patti and her husband, Jack, have been members of CEH since 1978. She thoroughly enjoys living in the mountains of Grand County, and loves the CEH family.

patti applebeeKrissy Morrow, Program Director, Teacher

  • Early Childhood Director Qualified
  • CPR and First Aid Certified
  • Universal Precaution Trained
  • Medication Administration Trained
  • Attended Appalachian State University
  • Graduated with Bachelor’s Degree
  • Early childhood professional for 17+ years
  • Married 10+ years
  • 2 young children, and 2 Boxers
  • Grand County resident for 16 years
  • Loves cooking, reading, four wheeling and especially being a mother